Skip to main contentSkip to navigationSkip to navigation

Readers suggest the 10 best second albums

This article is more than 9 years old

Last week we brought you our 10 best second albums. Here, we present your thoughts on those albums that should have made the list

Cover of Siamese Dream by Smashing Pumpkins
Photograph: Album cover

Siamese Dream, Smashing Pumpkins, 1993

Suggested by: MarkASmith, ID5374758, Domn8tricks

In 1993, Smashing Pumpkins released an album that was to solidify their place in the alternative rock world of music. Siamese Dream eventually became known as one of the best albums of the 90s. This was a relief for the band, under immense pressure after being labelled “the next Nirvana”.

The Temptations. Photograph: Michael Ochs Archives Photograph: Michael Ochs Archives

The Temptations Sing Smokey, The Temptations, 1965

Suggested by: salfordexile66

An entire album containing songs that were written and produced by none other than Smokey Robinson, frontman and founder of the Miracles, made the Temptations’s classic-filled second release. It reached No 1 in the US top R&B albums chart at the time, and is regarded by salfordexile66, and many others, as an “all-time favourite”.

Photograph: Album cover

Paul’s Boutique, Beastie Boys, 1989

Suggested by: piscolahm

Hip-hop group the Beastie Boys made their first appearance in 1986 and were immediately commercially successful. Their second album, Paul’s Boutique, however, was more experimental; piscolahm claims it “brilliantly showed they were the real deal and [so] produced one of the great hip-hop albums”.

JIMI HENDRIX
Photograph: Allstar/Sportsphoto Photograph: Sportsphoto Ltd./Allstar

Axis: Bold as Love, Jimi Hendrix, 1967

Suggested by: IgnatiusKWryly, mutie

Not long after Hendrix’s debut album earlier in the year, Axis: Bold as Love was released in December and spent 16 weeks in the charts. Containing some of the wildest compositions he ever recorded, the album also went through a range of studio techniques, including Hendrix’s guitar being played through a rotating Leslie speaker on the track Little Wing.

Photograph: Album cover

The Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan, Bob Dylan, 1963

Suggested by: RafasRegrets and kev01

The Freewheelin’ opens with one of Dylan’s most treasured compositions, Blowin’ in the Wind, and began an acclaimed songwriting career that led to international celebrity.

Carole King. Photograph: Ronald Grant Archive Photograph: Ronald Grant Archive

Tapestry, Carole King, 1971

Suggested by: GhostWiper and keithgnield01

Carole King’s Tapestry is one of the best-selling albums of all time, having shifted more than 25m copies internationally, and claimed four Grammy awards in 1972. King was involved in the writing of every single track on the album. GhostWiper says: “Almost every song on it is a classic.”

Cover of Radiohead's The Bends
Photograph: Album cover

The Bends, Radiohead, 1995

Suggested by: Brian Horsburgh and willonone

There was a certain amount of anger on the comments thread at Radiohead’s second effort not being included in the initial list. It was better received by critics than their debut and also marked a turn in the road for Thom Yorke’s songwriting, according to the band, having grown and matured from an angsty debut record.

Cover of Dr Dre's album 2001
Photograph: Album cover

2001, Dr Dre, 1999

Suggested by: Max Whitefoot

In it’s first week alone, 2001 sold more than 516,000 copies. Dre featured several other rappers on his second album, including Snoop Dogg and Eminem, and while its lyrics got a mixed reception, overall most of the reviews were positive. Dr Dre hadn’t released a solo album since The Chronic seven years before.

Shane MacGowan of the Pogues. Photograph: Peter Still/Redferns Photograph: Peter Still/Redferns

Rum, Sodomy and the Lash, the Pogues, 1985

Suggested by: RadioPartizan and Didescharlie

Didescharlie gives the Pogues’ Rum, Sodomy and the Lash “a million recommendations”. The Celtic punk sound the Pogues are so well-loved for helps to create an album often regarded as the high point of their career.

Photograph: Album cover

If You’re Feeling Sinister, Belle & Sebastian, 1996

Suggested by: SonOfTheDesert and DrewJarviesCombover

DrewJarviesCombover claims that “The Stars of Track and Field, and Judy and the Dream of Horses is probably about the best start and end to any album, never mind second albums”.

Comments (…)

Sign in or create your Guardian account to join the discussion

Most viewed

Most viewed