President Obama Honors Medal Of Freedom Recipients

Staff

MLK and Malcolm X

CAROLYN BRYANT

For The Washington Post

The Washington Post

staff

Birmingham’s ‘Fifth Girl’

Leroy Moton

Wichita-Sedgwick County Historical Museum

other

Aerial over Richmond, Virginia

iStock

stock

Jackson, Mississippi - Old State Capitol

Hubert Humphrey Addressing the Democratic National Convention

Bettmann Archive/Getty Images

Florida Historical Society

Civil rights activists attacked by white supremacist


© Danny Lyon / Magnum Photos

Mississippi Department of Archives and History

Theresa Ann Walker after her arrest as a Freedom Rider in 1961.

Black Panther leader killed in gun fight with police

Eleanor Roosevelt with National Youth Administration Leaders

Bettmann

Respond to prefers-color-scheme dark in app web views

Follow section front redirects in Spectrum

Enable NLP source in PCS for load testing

Switch off the News Alerts Survey Widget when we have enough responses

Poll to determine if new LUF updates are available

Allows the winning A/B test variant to be turned on without Spectrum deployment

Show infinite scrolling sections in Assembler MultiView

Show option for NLP article summaries in Action Bar

A general feature flag for Recipe Features that aren't yet released

Feature flag for media team features that aren't yet released

Use new Orca video player for preroll plugin in Spectrum

Show the snow tracker (instead of the heat tracker) on Spectrum

The 6 best things to do with kids in the D.C. area this weekend 

The 33 best things to do in D.C. this weekend and next week

Trevor Williams’s escape act helps Nationals blank Rangers 

Young Georgians want to be part of Europe. Their government is in the way.

On Press Freedom Day, little to celebrate for Hong Kong’s journalists

Taxes are inevitable. Paying to prepare them doesn’t have to be.

This masterpiece ‘Birth of Venus’ probably isn’t of Venus at all

The beginner’s illustrated guide to watching an F1 race

Wait, what is Stephen A. Smith talking about? Find out with our quiz.

Stephen A. Smith would like even more of your attention

Local sports networks go dark mid-game amid dispute with Comcast 

NASA moon capsule suffered extensive damage during 2022 test flight

Russian state media ramping up English, Spanish presence on TikTok, study finds

Apple is behind in AI and killed its self-driving car project. What’s next?

Chinese EVs are good for the world. Biden says they’re bad for America. 

Why the Solomon Islands election matters to China and the U.S.

Biden calls ally Japan ‘xenophobic’ like China, Russia, at campaign event

That time football legend, rig-driving eligible bachelor Biden was arrested

Trump and allies say Biden pays rent for ‘illegals’ in Michigan. Not true.

Eighty percent of Ukraine-Israel bill will be spent in U.S. or by U.S. military

Miss Manners: Offering my bedroom to guests

Ask Amy: My wife’s sister confessed her feelings for me

Carolyn Hax: Will request for a postnup offend much younger wife?

Cat climbed into Amazon return box, found alive 630 miles away

Brave Little Hunter is free: Baby orca escapes lagoon for open seas

I learned to heal my sadness by cradling dying chickens 

What’s the best bus to New York? We tested 5 for comfort and value.

You asked: Do I need a passport for my cruise?

Adaptive equipment is making national parks more inclusive

World Press Freedom Day, 2024

How Trump convinces Republicans to adopt extreme views

Campuses are grappling with the Gaza war. So are our columnists.

US President Joe Biden Departure

HENRY GRIFFIN

Jonathan Eig was deep in the Duke University archives researching his <a href="https://amzn.to/42FxnvR" target=_blank>new biography</a> of the Rev. <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/longterm/mlk/legacy/legacy.htm" target=_blank>Martin Luther King Jr.</a> when he made an alarming discovery: King’s harshest and most famous criticism of <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/history/2021/11/17/malcolm-x-assasination-who-why/" target=_blank>Malcolm X</a>, in which he accused his fellow civil rights leader of “fiery, demagogic oratory,” appears to have been fabricated.

“I think its historic reverberations are huge,” Eig told The Washington Post. “We’ve been teaching people for decades, for generations, that King had this harsh criticism of Malcolm X, and it’s just not true.”

The quote came from a January 1965 Playboy interview with author <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/history/2022/02/05/alex-haley-readers-digest-roots-malcolm/" target=_blank>Alex Haley</a>, a then-43-year-old Black journalist, and was the longest published interview King ever did. Because of the severity of King’s criticism, it has been repeated countless times, cast as a dividing line between King and <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/fifty-years-after-his-death-malcolm-x-speaks-to-the-current-moment/2015/02/19/4dba5ca4-091e-4303-b3ee-6a655c583655_story.html" target=_blank>Malcolm X</a>. The new revelation “shows that King was much more open-minded about Malcolm than we’ve tended to portray him,” Eig said.

Who killed Martin Luther King Jr.? His family believes James Earl Ray was framed.

Haley’s legacy has been tarnished by accusations of <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1978/12/15/bethesda-author-settles-roots-suit-for-500000/f97b693c-5336-46b3-8ab0-1b19856e8964/" target=_blank>plagiarism</a> and historical inaccuracy in his most famous book, “<a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/local/1977/02/24/alex-haley-says-roots-helped-dispel-myths/4e417376-71ed-44ec-8a03-d6c21bbdcee2/" target=_blank>Roots</a>,” but this latest finding could open up more of his work to criticism, especially “<a href="https://www.amazon.com/Autobiography-Malcolm-Told-Alex-Haley/dp/0345350685" target=_blank>The Autobiography of Malcolm X: As Told to Alex Haley</a>” — released just months after Malcolm X’s assassination in 1965.

Malcolm X, a member of the Nation of Islam, had frequently attacked King and his commitment to nonviolence, going so far as to call King a “modern Uncle Tom.” But his criticism often had “strategic purposes,” Eig said.

In acting as “a foil” to King, his message had more value to the media. “King saw value in being a foil to Malcolm sometimes, too. But I think at their core they had a lot in common. They certainly shared a lot of the same goals,” Eig said.

Farrar, Straus and Giroux

Eig, who previously wrote acclaimed biographies of Muhammad Ali and Lou Gehrig, said he found the fabrication in the course of his standard book research for “King: A Life,” due out May 16. When a subject has given a long interview, he’ll look through the archives of the journalist who conducted it, hoping to find notes or tapes with previously unpublished anecdotes.

He did not find a recording of Haley’s interview with King in the Haley archives at Duke, but he did find what appears to be an unedited transcript of the full interview, likely typed by a secretary straight from a recording, Eig said. Eig provided The Post with a copy of the transcript.

Martin Luther King Jr. met Malcolm X just once. The photo still haunts us with what was lost.

On Page 60 of the 84-page document, Haley asks, “Dr. King, would you care to comment upon the articulate former Black Muslim, Malcolm X?”

King responds: “I have met Malcolm X, but circumstances didn’t enable me to talk with him for more than a minute. I totally disagree with many of his political and philosophical views, as I understand them. He is very articulate, as you say. I don’t want to seem to sound as if I feel so self-righteous, or absolutist, that I think I have the only truth, the only way. Maybe he does have some of the answer. But I know that I have so often felt that I wished that he would talk less of violence, because I don’t think that violence can solve our problem. And in his litany of expressing the despair of the Negro, without offering a positive, creative approach, I think that he falls into a rut sometimes.”

That is not how King’s response appeared in the <a href="https://alexhaley.com/2020/07/26/alex-haley-interviews-martin-luther-king-jr/" target="_blank">published interview</a>. While the top part is nearly identical with the transcript, it ended in Playboy like this: “And in his litany of articulating the despair of the Negro without offering any positive, creative alternative, I feel that Malcolm has done himself and our people a great disservice. Fiery, demagogic oratory in the black ghettos, urging Negroes to arm themselves and prepare to engage in violence, as he has done, can reap nothing but grief.”

Some of the phrases added to King’s answer appear to be taken significantly out of context, while others appear to be fabricated:

“ … I feel that Malcolm has done himself and our people a great disservice.” King does not say this or anything similar anywhere in the 84-page interview transcript.

“Fiery, demagogic oratory in the black ghettos, urging Negroes to arm themselves and prepare to engage in violence …” King says this phrase much earlier in the transcript, on Page 12, and in answer to the question: “Dr. King, what is your opinion of Negro extremists who advocate armed violence and sabotage?” King gives a lengthy response that begins: “Fiery, demagogic oratory in the black ghettoes urging Negroes to arm themselves and prepare to engage in violence can achieve nothing but negative results.”

“ … as he has done …” King does not name Malcolm X as an example of “fiery, demagogic oratory” anywhere in the transcript.

“ … can reap nothing but grief.” This phrase does not appear in the transcript.

It is a standard practice in journalism when publishing Q&amp;A-style interviews to make minor changes, such as removing excessive “ums” or truncating long answers where the subject repeats their point over and over again or wanders from the topic at hand. But journalists typically take great pains to ensure any changes do not alter the intended meaning of an interviewee’s response. In addition, outlets commonly will include an editor’s note informing the reader of such changes.

What Haley appears to have done amounts to “journalistic malpractice,” Eig said.

“We should remember that King was always more <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2022/01/19/mlk-day-speech/" target=_blank>radical</a> than we like to imagine or talk about,” Eig continued. “He was a Christian radical, and his radicalism came from a different place than Malcolm’s did, but they always had a lot in common. They always believed that you had to take radical steps to change America, to end racism, to create a country that lived up to the words of its promises.”

Indeed, in another part of the transcript, Haley asks King about critics labeling him an “extremist,” to which King responded: “At first, it disturbed me. Then I began to consider that, yes, I would like to think myself an extremist — in the light of Christ-like spirit which made Jesus an extremist for love.”

George Brich

King never commented on the interview, and it is not known whether he was even aware of the changed quotes, Eig said. “He was extremely busy, he had a lot of other problems going on, and in general, he never complained about any media coverage,” Eig said. “He had bigger fish to fry.”

Eig has shared his discovery with a number of King scholars, and the changes “jumped out” to them as “a real fraud,” he said. “They’re like, ‘Oh my God, I’ve been teaching that to my students for years,’ and now they have to rethink it,” Eig said.

One of these scholars is Peniel E. Joseph, director of the Center for the Study of Race and Democracy at the University of Texas at Austin and the author of <a href="https://www.amazon.com/s?k=peniel+joseph&crid=3MKE8BJ3WBKXJ&sprefix=peniel+joseph%2Caps%2C75&ref=nb_sb_noss_1" target=_blank>a number of books</a> about the civil rights and Black power movements. He told The Post he would change how he teaches now that Eig’s “terrific” research was “setting the historical record straight.”

Given Haley’s other scandals, “this is not really surprising or shocking, but it’s bad,” Joseph said.

“We know on other occasions King is talking about Malcolm X without mentioning him at all,” Joseph said. “In this specific case, we have more clarification about how certain media wanted to pit them against each other and use Dr. King as a cudgel against Malcolm.”

King and Malcolm X <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/retropolis/wp/2018/01/14/martin-luther-king-jr-met-malcolm-x-just-once-the-photo-still-haunts-us-with-what-was-lost/" target="_blank">met only once</a>, and briefly, outside a Senate hearing at the U.S. Capitol on March 26, 1964. Weeks before, Malcolm X had announced his break with the Nation of Islam and its leader, Elijah Muhammad, and his willingness to work with other civil rights leaders.

When the men met, he told King, “I’m throwing myself into the heart of the civil rights struggle.”

Malcolm X didn’t fear being killed: ‘I live like a man who is dead already’

Haley, who spent much of his life struggling to pay the bills, may have decided to emphasize or exaggerate King’s and Malcolm X’s differences to increase his public profile, Joseph suggested.

In this same period, between 1963 and 1965, Haley was also conducting a series of interviews that would become Malcolm X’s autobiography, as Malcolm X allegedly told it to him. “I believe that what we know about this incident, and others that we know about Alex Haley, should prompt us to scrutinize everything he’s written, including the autobiography,” Eig said.

Joseph is more cautious, saying that even if Haley “took license with it,” all autobiographies should be understood as “a literary creation” and not an exact historical record. Still, educators using the autobiography in their classes teach students to “think critically” about it, he said.

In the end, King “was not afraid to criticize Malcolm, but he was also willing to listen to him, and he was not ruling him out as a crackpot, as a violent wild card. He was thinking about Malcolm and where he belonged on the team of people fighting for justice,” Eig said.

Whatever thoughts King may have had about working with Malcolm X in the future, no such partnership would come to pass. Malcolm X was <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/history/2021/02/22/malcolm-x-assassination-letter-nypd-fbi/" target=_blank>assassinated</a> on Feb. 21, 1965, a month after the King interview published.

This story has been updated with additional comments by Eig on King’s awareness of the changed quotes.

A previous version of this article misstated when Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X met. It was March 26, 1964, not 1963. The article has been corrected.

NABJ Salute to Excellence Award for digital commentary, 2018

Emmy nomination for new approaches: documentary, 2017

Northwestern University, MS in journalism 

University of Texas at Austin, BA in history and English

Gillian Brockell is a staff writer for The Washington Post’s history blog, Retropolis. She has been at The Post since 2013 and previously worked as a video editor. 

Gillian Brockell

washpost

MLK’s famous Playboy criticism of Malcolm X was a ‘fraud,’ author says

the-washington-post

MLK’s famous criticism of Malcolm X was a ‘fraud,’ author finds

(Henry Griffin/AP)

name

prism://prism.query/site,/local/retropolis?limit=20

Retropolis

prism://prism.query/site,/history&limit=20

History

prism://prism.query/site-articles-only,/national&limit=20

National

The Washington Post's national news coverage. Get the latest national news, featuring national security, science and the courts. Read breaking national news headlines from across the U.S.